Your readers might appreciate the MPR story on Cass County where Trump won 62% of the vote with Clinton getting 31% and independents getting 7%. The Trump voters still support him but do not like the Republicans plans to cut Medicaid.
Here’s the interesting sidenote …. in 2016 Cass County, Trump (9982) outperformed Mills (9407) with others getting 1068 votes while Nolan (6287) outperformed Clinton (4949). Voters side with the MN-GOP candidates in the state Minnesota 9709 versus 5666 and the state House contests 9710-5560.
Compare that to 2012 Cass County, Romney won 8957 to Obama 6858 with 210 votes going to others. In the House, Cravaack won 8086 to Nolan 7199.
Strictly looking at Cass County, my assessment is the county will always tend to vote for the GOP candidate … and the best argument is that with the legislature being controlled by the Republicans (in Congress as well as in Minnesota), that if you want to protect yourself from Republican policy views, ya better vote for the opposition.
How do you factor in the cost of college ?
And the argument that colleges may not prepare you for today’s jobs ?
Let me put on my GOP cap — and ignoring the chatter that universities are home to brainwashing liberals (except of course, Liberty, George Mason, Pepperdine, Rice, etc.), and I read that student debt is crippling recent graduates, state colleges are asking for more money, there are no jobs for many graduates because they do not have the right skills.
Then I get a mass mailing from my Republican Congressman telling me how he is working to change the “Skills gap” to create jobs for our kids.
Of course the mass mailing never mentions the student debt related to For-Profit schools — University of Phoenix, Capella University, DeVry University, National American University, etc … and that those schools who stress you will get a job have such low job placement rates as well as low graduation rates.
It becomes easy to blame colleges.
And once again the Republicans win the message contest.
“The right wing had a good election in Minnesota in 2016 because rural DFLers skipped this one and rural swing voters went for Trump. That’s bad.”
Tony offers some very good analysis … although, my impression is that if he included the mid-term years, he would find that it is even more apparent that the MN-GOP consistently gets its voters to participate (look to when the MN-GOP retook the House in 2014,what was the MinnPost headline — “With big assist from rural voters, GOP retakes House”.
Let us remember that Mark Dayton topped Republican Tom Emmer by roughly 9000 votes in 2010 but Dayton won big in 2014 against Jeff Johnson by over 109,000.
The total number of votes in 2010 was 2,106,979.
The total number of votes in 2014 was 1,975,406.
So why was able to Dayton able to squeak by in 2010 but blow out the GOP challenger when less people voted ?
The answer is in the strength of the third-party … to provide a reason for people to go to the polls to cast a “Anybody but” vote. In 2010, Tom Horner lead the third-party challengers with over 250,000 while all the third-party challengers in 2014 didn’t even tally over 110,000.
Now, when you look at Trump’s almost win, you see how much more likely it could have been when you consider the votes that Evan McMullin and Gary Johnson tallied more than 166,000 votes … easily more than enough to have overcome Clinton’s roughly 44,000 margin.
Also, let’s not forget that the Lewis-Craig contested was impacted by the 7.8% of the votes that went to Independent Party challenger Overby.
IMO, the MN-GOP promotes (fear mongers) the issues (abortion, guns, regulations, government overreach, immigrants taking jobs, taxes, etc.) that drives people to participate … and on Election Night, they prove that fear wins.
FYI : CHOICE stands for Creating Hope and Opportunity for Investors, Consumers and Entrepreneurs
Doesn’t that say it all “Hope investors send us campaign donaitons”
Tom Emmer was the lone Minnesotan to sponsor #HR10 but was joined by Erik Paulsen and Jason Lewis in voting for the legislation (all Democrats voted NO.)
It should be pointed out that the one Republican who voted NO issued a statement explaining why — it would be harmful to veterans. Why this was not a concern for Representatives Emmer, Lewis and Paulsen is something worthy of an election question.
Actually, there were a number of organizations that voiced concern (see the MN Political Roundtable review of Erik Paulsen’s claims of why this legislation was necessary — yep, they are outrageous.)
On the overall subject of gerrymandering and the apathy that follows, your readers may appreciate this article reviewing all the states and the impact of “partisan selection”.
Just makes you know how important the 2018 and 2020 state legislative elections are.
Screwing veterans is not reserved just for the Trump White House as Tom Emmer sponsored while Jason Lewis and Erik Paulsen enthusiastically voted in support of HR10 the Financial CHOICE Act.
The Financial CHOICE Act removes the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s ability to regulate small-dollar loans, like payday loans, despite evidence of pervasive predatory practices focused on service members. This alarmed numerous national veterans and active duty service organizations, prompting the Veterans of Foreign Wars (VFW) to recommend a NO vote on the Emmer/Lewis/Paulsen bill.
Some good news … and I gotta give some thanks to Collin Peterson and the 56 other bipartisan Members who wrote to VA Secretary Shulkin about proposed budget cuts to end Individual Unemployment program which provides unemployment benefits to more than 200,000 disabled senior veterans with a 60 to 100 percent disability rating.
Today, the word is that the White House is backing off that cut … what is still not certain is if they will still push to “round down” any COLA adjustments for veterans — that could save $20 million in 2018.
If you have heard my story of the CUB cashier before, just skip this paragraph.
While waiting in line for the cashier to get a price check, she noticed my hat — a John Kerry for President cap. It was 2004, the Iraq situation was a big issue but that did not seem to be her issue when she said to me “So you’re a Kerry guy … I’m just not sure about him … he’s gonna raise my taxes.” Not sure what her wage was, but said “No, Bush tax cuts have helped the wealthy … shifting tax burden to workers and increased our national debt while Kerry just wants to roll back the tax cuts on the wealthy.” She responded “yeah, but I still don’t trust him.”
Trump understood the CUB cashier … who saw people paying for groceries with food stamps while she worked … and saw that incursion of automated checkout lines — eliminating cashiers.
So, Trump could be getting some erosion of support … but those voters may still be afraid of the Dems.
The question is will the CUB cashier bother to vote ?
Let’s look at Minnesota’s Second District … and compare the Presidential election years
2012 … 90.1% of the registered voters participated and Kline got 54% of the vote and Obermueller got 46%.
2014 … while the total number of registered voters increased by over 26,000 only just over 12,000 actually voted … reducing the participation rate to 87.4%. MNGOP Lewis won with 47%, DFLer Craig got 45% and IP Overby got 8%.
Beyond that, we know that there are an estimated 49,000 people who are not registered.
That is really the challenge … how do you get people to vote. And some may have felt obligated to vote for Congress and just decided that neither Lewis or Craig was their choice, so they simply “wasted” their vote on Overby. (BTW … consider that TrumpCare was passed with one vote to spare, shouldn’t there be a lot of anger at the inability to excite the voters with Craig’s candidacy … heck, she barely beat Obermueller’s total (she only moved the DFL tally up 2,977) … so why is she being mentioned again this cycle?)
While, this is easily seen as a problem in MN02. consider how the Minnesota legislature has been taken over by the MNGOP, and you gotta be concerned. Look at Walz-Hagedorn race in MN01 … Walz had money to burn and was an incumbent, yet the contest was very close (close enough that Norm Coleman has already sent money to Hagedorn for his 2018 campaign.)
Yeah … there may be some positive trends … but let’s remember that Montana just elected another Republican millionaire in a Special Election (as they did in Kansas) … their margins may have been closer, but they still won.
Dems have to have a better message … not just bashing Trump and Russia … why aren’t they asking “Where’s Trump’s infrastructure bill ?”
Good story of the changing view of Trump supporters can be illustrated by Kraig Moss. “He promised me, in honor of my son, that he was going to combat the ongoing heroin epidemic. He got me hook, line and sinker.”
Moss, an amateur musician, quickly sold enough possessions to fund a months-long tour of more than 40 Trump rallies, where he serenaded voters with pro-Trump songs. His guitar, and the ashes of his late 24-year-old son, Rob, were always close by.
Now, the Trump Budget is out and the White House is proposing cutting the budget for the Office of National Drug Control Policy by 95 percent—a reduction in funds akin to effective elimination.
The ONDCP runs two programs that form the backbone of many of the opioid-related efforts at the local level—the Drug-Free Communities Support Program and the High Intensity Drug Trafficking Areas program. These initiatives provide funding, resources and guidance to local government entities on a wide range of drug-related issues.
So, the programs still are needed … but it may be the States that will be forced to fund them.
That is in essence the GOP / Trump strategy … not eliminate programs just reduce the federal funds … most likely by using “block grants” and let the individual State decide … that’s the RyanCare plan for healthcare … and the DeVos plan for education.
IMO, Democrats should ignore the Russia stories and focus on the Trump budget … especially when Jason Lewis so proudly praises Budget chief Mulvaney (who readers should know that during Senate hearings stated that the HouseGOP target of cutting $800 billion in Medicaid through AHCA, is just one step as the TrumpBudget is looking at total Medicaid cuts up to $1.4 Trillion.
There is good reasons that Kiffmeyer’s bill should not be approved — even by Republicans who must realize that their personal information will be available for anyone to review.
But isn’t the real problem that people just don’t vote … even with the system is easier today with the “no excuse early voting”.
The big vote last week in the House was the approval of TrumpCare … and Minnesota played a key role in that outcome.
It was approved with one vote to spare … meaning that Erik Paulsen was exposed.
Paulsen and others would have gotten even more pressure if Jason Lewis wasn’t there protecting them.
Should Jason Lewis have been there … did people realize that when they decided to cast their vote that their healthcare would be changed … his campaign was based on repealing Obamacare, so no one should have been surprised … yet would they vote today, if they knew what they know now ?
Lewis beat Angie Craig by 6,655 but 29,229 voted for someone else while 53,531 were registered but didn’t vote. Reports are that there were another 49K that are not registered.
America has an apathy problem … the challenge for all politicians is how to get more people to participate … Kiffmeyer’s bill will not help.
FYI : Did you know that Republicans Dave Trott (MI-11) and Jack Bergman (MI-01) along with Democrat Debbie Dingell (MI-12) have introduced H.R.458 – Preserve Our Lakes and Keep Our Environment Safe Act.
Don’t be shocked that Minnesotans Emmer, Lewis and Paulsen have ignored their bill.
The Enbridge pipeline that passes through Wisconsin – Michigan has had at least 29 leaks in its 64-year history—spilling more than 1 million gallons of oil and gas liquids and even Enbridge acknowledged that where the pipeline crosses under the Straits of Mackinac, there are 18 points that have “delaminated,” meaning an outer casing has fallen off.
Read more here.
Suggested reading retail job losses … the list does not include Gander Mountain which is closing 32 stores including 3 in Minnesota … plus in some deep red states like Alabama and Texas.
What does it say when selling guns and ammo isn’t enough to keep these stores open ?
In a report published earlier this month, Credit Suisse analysts said the big four sportsman superstore operators together have lost steam. Credit Suisse forecast growth of below 10 percent this year. That follows several years when the superstore chains posted growth rates of more than 20 percent.
These job losses will make workers uneasy … which should be a major concern for Erik Paulsen/Jason Lewis as many of the job losses will impact women (BLS reports that 75% of clothing stores and 60% of department store workers are women) … they will see their healthcare costs going up with TrumpCare.
It will be interesting to see how Lewis explains the change in the number of workers participating in the workforce … he has complained last year that a 62.9% labor force participation rate of 62.9% had to be corrected … the first months under Trump has barely moved it to 63.0%.
Funny thing is that today, I heard two commercials on the radio calling for job fairs … the one was from a local precision parts manufacturer — hiring second shift with wages starting at $15 for a physical job … the other was for Wal*Mart’s distribution center — starting wages at $17.
The retail industry is going through major changes … with more online-shopping purchases being delivered directly to your home. Go to your local grocery store where your loyalty card has preloaded sales discounts and automatic check-outs will lead to more job losses.
Hmmm … let’s see so if you are a woman who delivered a healthy baby and had no complications, you still get to pay more (last one on the list).
Good to know that there is not a War On Women any more … it’s a War On Mommies.
And let’s look at the third item on your list … Colorectal cancer is the third leading cause of cancer-related deaths in women in the United States and the second leading cause in men. It is expected to cause about 50,260 deaths during 2017. Of course, you could get screened … but that would mean that you would pay a higher premium … so is it better to just die ?
BTW … I guess that means that H.R. 1017 The Removing Barriers to Colorectal Cancer Screening Act, isn’t necessary anymore.
No wonder I see that Erik Paulsen has been tweeting pictures of him in doctor’s garb (most recently at Mercy Hospital with Dr. Stark performing a heart valve procedure … he must be checking up to be sure that everyone who meets #10 on the list gets to pay a little more.
FYI from the Business Insider
These changes were not enough for some members of the Freedom Caucus, according to reports. Rep. Jim Jordan of Ohio, a prominent member of the Freedom Caucus, told reporters that essential health benefit repeal was not enough and “it’s always been beyond that.”
The freedom Caucus has reportedly asked for a repeal of some “Title 1 provisions” in the ACA. These provisions do things like prevent insurers from denying coverage based on a pre-existing condition, allow children to stay on their parents insurance until they turn 26 years old, and annual limits on healthcare costs.
ICYMI #1. The New York Times reported that Robert S. Eitel, a former compliance officer at for-profit college operator Bridgepoint Education Inc., is working at the Education department. Eitel, a former deputy general counsel at the Education Department from 2006 to 2009, has been a critic of federal regulations on for-profit colleges. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau last September ordered Bridgepoint, Eitel’s former employer, to refund $23.5 million to students whom it had deceived into taking out loans that cost more than advertised. Bridgepoint is currently under investigation by the Department of Justice, the Securities and Exchange Commission, and the attorneys general of New York, North Carolina, California and Massachusetts.
ICYMI #2. Federal marshals are protecting Education Secretary Betsy DeVos at a cost of $7.8 million through September (the fiscal year end).
ICYMI #3. The House will like vote (and pass) HR1387 which will authorize funding for DC Charter Schools (would cost $315 million over 5 yrs) … remember Congress authorizes and controls all spending for the District … so they can allow states to use federal dollars for charter schools in their states, but with the DC schools they can actually give out the money.
Canary in the coal mine ?
Hmmm … but didn’t I hear that Donald Trump was gonna save the coal miners ???
Seriously, we see restaurant chains open and close all the time … but the bigger concern should be the demise of retail stores.
Sears is shutting down about 10% of its Sears and Kmart locations, or 150 stores, and JCPenney is shutting down about 14% of its locations, or 138 stores. Payless, Gordman’s, Gander Mountain, etc.
More than 3,500 stores are expected to close in the next couple of months.
There are reports that 60,000 people have been notified that they have lost their jobs … just in the past two months.
There are more retail job losses than there are working coal miners.
The concern that we should have is how many of these employees will lose their healthcare … admittedly, not every worker in retail participated in a health plan (29% according to one study) but other workers did have access to ObamaCare.
So when the Republicans finally do whatever they are gonna do with the ACA, there will be a lot more people that will be impacted.
The race isn’t even in Spring Training time, yet there is a story that Keith Ellison predicts that Tim Walz will be the next governor … of course, Walz would have to be the nominee … and beat any Republican, Independence Party and all other minor party candidates.
BTW … did you know that Jeffrey Wharton and running mate Amy Klobuchar got 53 votes in the 2016 Presidential Election ? Wharton is running this time for Governor as a Republican along with Phillip Parrish, Ole Savior, Chris Chamberlin as well as the most recently announced candidate Blake Huffman.
Let us remember that only Congress can declare war … so as the Syria situation escalates, let us remember that Tom Emmer offered (in 2015) H.J.Res.73 – Declaring that a state of war exists between the Islamic State and the Government and the people of the United States and making provision to prosecute the same.
Emmer got zero co-sponsors and no vote.
Fast forward to last month … 4 Republicans and 4 Democrats offered H.R.1666 – To prohibit the availability of funds for activities in the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan, and for other purposes.
Don’t expect HR 1666 to get any traction either.
Congress would rather let the President — regardless if it was Reagan, Clinton, Bush or Obama — take the flack.
Hey there are energy jobs coming to America … may be you missed it but Mike Pence is in Ohio right now … and there is a report that 15 new full-time employees will be added to the utility system staff at The Ohio State University.
Oh, it should be mentioned that Ohio State is about to privatize its energy that is used on campus for the next 50 years.
Oh, it should be mentioned that this was an opening bidding process … all three were foreign concerns … and the winner is ENGIE-Axium, a French company.
The Ohio State Board of Trustees will meeting on April 7 to approve lease and receive the $1.015 billion upfront payment immediately.
Privatization is not new at Ohio State … they previously sold off its parking operation in a 50-year, $483 million deal.
The University of Oklahoma is the only other public university who has an outside company run the operation of its utilities. In 2010, Oklahoma leased the control of its utilities for 50 years, worth $118 million.
Quite being so judgemental … how could you not mention that Tom Emmer got another co-sponsor — his first in two months — for H.R.534 – U.S. Wants to Compete for a World Expo Act.
You know that piece of legislation so that taxpayers can pay back dues so that Minnesota can seek a World’s Fair in 2023. Of course, there is no guarantee that Minnesota will get it … and we know that this would be the highlight of Trump’s second term.
Now, everyone please say after me :
Trump is the greatest President ever and Tom Emmer is the greatest Congressman ever
(sorry Erik Paulsen but you were not smart enough to realize the potential of a World’s Fair.)
If it’s true that Government grants made up just $248,347 of the Meals-on-Wheels funding, that is an easy number that Congress could offset … just tell Erik Paulsen to stop sending those mass mailings (FYI – 2016 taxpayers paid $77,177.33 for Franked Mail), tele-town hall meetings ( let’s put in another $20K), bonuses to his staff (another $20K) and were halfway there.
Considering how Paulsen would rather spending YOUR taxdollars on mailers, the message to seniors is “Let ’em eat paper”.
Have any of the Minnesota Republicans in Congress stated their observations ?
Don’t be surprised if they don’t object to Veterans spending too much — Trump’s 2018 Budget requests $78.9 billion in discretionary funding for VA, a
$4.4 billion or 6 percent increase from the 2017 enacted level — but it should be noted that Obama didn’t get what he asked for ($75.2 billion but got close).
There are some cuts that have no effect on Minnesota — like spending that benefits Alaska (i.e. the Denali Commission, which coordinates state-federal infrastructure project) or regions, such as, Appalachian Regional Commission, a federal-state partnership focused on economic development in a region encompassing all of West Virginia and parts of Pennsylvania, Ohio, Kentucky, Alabama, Georgia, Maryland, Mississippi, New York, North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee, and Virginia.
There are some national cuts that might impact Minnesota and thus putting Jason Lewis in the spotlight. Lewis sits on the Budget and Transportation Committees … and one of the programs being eliminated is Essential Air Service for smaller airports (last I heard, Bemidji, Brainerd, International Fall, Hibbing and Thief River Falls had EAS service). Yep, there is some taxpayer cost but a big portion of the bill is funded from overflight fees paid to FAA by foreign aircraft that transit U.S. airspace without landing in or taking off from the United States.
Another one is the Great Lakes Lakes Restoration Initiative which is targeted to be defunded — Great so we are building a wall on the Mexican border while the Asian Carp takeover our waters. Smart thinking Trump.
Hopefully, all cuts are reviewed … and not just the high-profile programs like Meals-On-Wheels.
Yet, remember this is Trump’s Budget REQUEST … it is up to the House GOP lead by Emmer, Lewis and Paulsen that will really decide this.
QUESTION : If they had voted to raise the pay from the current $31,140 to … let’s say … $100 a year since their last raise — 1999 … so for simple math, it be under $33,000 … would Daudt still bellyache ?
You know the answer is yes.
A couple of things to consider, this recommendation was approved by Council members by a vote of 13-1. Kenneth Wilmes was the lone vote against it … Ken Wilmes is a Republican from the Mankato area … and since the board was established with 8 Republicans, doesn’t that suggest at least some thought it was a fair wage ?
OK … so we are gonna pay a “part-time” legislator $45,000 … and we know that they spend a lot of that “part-time” work outside of the legislative session in various working groups and committees throughout the year.
Now, as a comparison, did you realize that Erik Paulsen is essentially a small business owner … he has a Congressional Staff of maybe 13 full-time people …. (plus others who are “shared” employees. Wanna guess how many of them have an annual salary more than $45,000 ? How about ten ! And we really won’t know about Christmas/YearEnd bonuses — because the #MathGuy does not issue a press release — but a number of them got $4,000 to $5,000 bumps in pay during the fourth quarter.
I know that you cannot compare the a federal job with a state legislator job but when Paulsen is paying the person who answers the telephone to tell you that “Congressman Paulsen does not hold town hall meetings but if you would like me to schedule him to visit your child’s school, I can help you” — essentially same amount as a Minnesota legislator, there is a problem.
Ok … a couple of thoughts here …
1. Daudt and any other Member can simply send a check back to the state for increase … believe it or not but Tim Walz has returned the last salary increase that Congress awarded for years … retired Congressman Chris Gibson didn’t think it was right for him to get a military pension plus a Congressional salary, so he donated his pension pay … and Elise Stefanik pays back the “subsidy” she gets for her “Gold” level ACA plan (hey, it’s not much just $251.18/mo)
2. If they are concerned about the compensation, simply reduce the size of the state legislature. Why not consider a unicameral legislature … take out 134 state reps at $31,140 and increase the pay for the State Senators.
Instead of focusing on Trump, why not look at the down ballot races.
Why did Jason Lewis win ?
Why did Tim Walz barely squeak by against un-financed opponent ?
In Minnesota, the Republicans took over the state legislature completely … thus, ya gotta ask WHY are people not voting … and for those that vote, why Republican ?
OK … they got a base that is reliable with the Guns God Gays and Gynecology issues, but it is also economic. They talk to the “CUB cashier” who hears the message that there is someone else getting a free pass and that taxes need to be cut.
Let us remember that Trump could have likely won if not for the minority candidates — Gary Johnson (112,972) and Evan McMullin (53,076) — as Clinton’s margin was less than 45,000.
Thus ya gotta ask who did the Trump/Johnson/McMullin voter go for in the state legislature contests (Trump won the Second garnering more votes that Lewis).
Yet, Minnesota may have had a problem from not having a US Senate race — remember that Stewart Mills III said he felt better about 2016 because Franken would not be on the ballot — and instead look to another state that you cite — Wisconsin.
Wisconsin did have a Senate race … one that many thought would be a “for sure” Democrat pick-up … but in the end, Ron Johnson once again defeated Russ Feingold … by almost 100,000 votes.
Think about it … Tammy Badwin won in a non-Presidential year garnering 1,547,104 votes versus ex-Gov Tommy Thompson with 1,380,126.
Compare that to the presidential year (2016) Senate vote
Johnson 1,478,170 Feingold 1,378,922
So, somehow in a non-presidential year, more people voted … and went Republican.
Yeah, in Wisconsin, Trump won … but the exit polls clearly showed that Obama was viewed favorably while Trump had unfavorable rating of 64%, 64% also said he was not qualified to be President and 59% worried that he did not have the temperament to be President … yet, he got more votes.
My thought is that there are really two things going on here.
1. People had Clinton fatigue and with the polls showing she would win, were willing to make a “statement” vote against her … thinking that Trump would never win … and if he did. so what, after all he was a businessman who would “create jobs” (LOL).
2. There is a real problem for the DFL … they are not getting the people to the polls.
My guess is that he was out “drinking up” praise for his hard work … after all, “Representative” Paulsen must have been tired after retweeting the praise he got from the Beer Institute — recognizing him as “a leader for the over 1.75 million Americans whose jobs rely on a dynamic #beer industry” … specifically for the “almost 43,000 Minnesotans whose jobs rely on a thriving beer industry.”
OK … following the instructions of our Supreme Leader Donald Trump never to trust the media … is the “almost 43,000” figure correct ?
Yes … it is … well actually the 2014 data from John Dunham and Associates puts the number at 42,912.
But that number includes the retail and marketing employees … the number of people working at breweries is only 667.
Heck, in 2014, Wal*Mart had 21,877 employees in Minnesota … and none of them brew beer or make any product.
So, why is Erik Paulsen getting praised … because he is the prime sponsor of HR 747 Craft Beverage Modernization and Tax Reform Act of 2017 … a tax cut that the industry wants. It’s a tax cut on the Federal Excise Tax … which Paulsen says will result in more jobs. Now, he can make the argument on the Medical Device Excise Tax that the businesses would invest in R&D resulting in more employees (still haven’t seen any proof that is justified) yet, ya gotta wonder if the brewers got a cut in their excise tax, would they really invest in making the “next great beer” … or just keep if in profits.
After all, the current tax which is passed onto consumers has not seemed to hamper business … With all 12 months of 2016 data now available, beer production grew by an estimated 700,000 barrels, or 0.3%, in 2016.
That’s product … not price.
Paulsen is a corporate shill … pushing every tax cut … and tricking people into believing that it will result in jobs.
No wonder he does not want to meet with ordinary citizens.
FYI Letter on behalf of the 3,800 hard-working Minnesotans that are
employed in the solar industry regarding HF235
This legislation, if enacted, will not only kill an important component of
Minnesota’s solar industry, it will also pull the rug out on solar businesses that have made investments and finalized contracts for solar projects this year. Repealing the Made in Minnesota Solar Incentive Program (MiM) three years into its ten-year cycle will negatively impact the entire solar industry value chain resulting in the immediate loss of investments and jobs throughout the state.
In 2013, the legislature – like most other legislatures around the country – developed a solar incentive program with a goal of establishing a Minnesota-based solar industry marketplace. The Made in Minnesota (MiM) program is succeeding in that endeavor. Since the enactment of MiM, Minnesota’s residential and small business sector of the solar industry has grown exponentially with over 1,100 installations. Businesses have opened their doors in big and small towns across the state and have offered employment opportunities to rural Minnesotans who had been economically displaced by the recession.
In some instances, businesses have even relocated from other states to take advantage of Minnesota’s solar-friendly policies. MiM has increased Minnesota’s ability to compete nationally in securing businesses in this sector while delivering economic benefits statewide.
According to the Minnesota Department of Commerce, MiM has been responsible for the creation of 495 jobs in Minnesota’s solar sector and the majority of the industry utilizes this program to market their products and services. Because of the MiM program, Minnesota’s small businesses are better able to compete with larger, out-of-state companies.
Just as other states are implementing new or stronger solar incentive programs, Minnesota is moving to eliminate its own. HF 235/SF 214 repeals the MiM program with immediate effect. Not only would this devastate our state’s strong and growing roof top solar industry, it instantly terminates funds set to be awarded on February 28, 2017—less than two weeks from today. What should our home-grown
businesses tell their customers? How can these companies recoup the investments they have already made?
How can Minnesota expect to continue to compete nationally in this fast-growing sector if we repeal this program and tell our solar business community we’ve changed our minds?
We urge you to vote “No” on this legislation and to support the continued growth of solar in Minnesota.
Thank you for your consideration.
1. Alexandria Industries
2. All Energy Solar
3. Applied Energy Innovations
4. Aquilla Solar
5. Cedar Creek Energy
6. Energy Concepts
7. Ideal Energy
8. Innovative Power Systems
9. iTek Energy
10. Powerfully Green
12. Solar Connection
13. Solar Farm
14. SunDance Energy Solutions
15. SunDial Solar
17. TruNorth Solar
18. Werner Electric
19. Winona Renewable Energy, LLC